Episode 107

full
Published on:

7th Jan 2026

Wealth Litigated - EP 107: Divorce Busting Irrevocable Trusts?

What happens when an irrevocable family trust holds over $2 million in marital assets, but excludes one spouse entirely upon divorce? This episode deconstructs the landmark Dahl v. Dahl (Utah Supreme Court, 2015) decision, where a single word in a trust document—and a massive procedural oversight—put a $2 million marital interest at risk.

Professor Kelly Lise Murray, JD, breaks down how "irrevocable" trusts can be unexpectedly revoked and why wealth professionals must understand the "settlor by contribution" rule to protect client assets.


What You’ll Learn

· The "Any" vs. "No" Clause: How a suspected typo transformed an irrevocable trust into a revocable one.


· Joinder Jeopardy: Why failing to name the trust as a party can tank a divorce case.


· Public Policy Overrides: When state law trumps a trust’s chosen jurisdiction (Utah vs. Nevada).


· Settlor Status: Why contributing money makes you a "creator" of a trust, even if you never signed the paperwork.



Case Background: Dahl v. Dahl

· The Setup: During an 18-year marriage, the husband created the "Dahl Family Irrevocable Trust".


· The Assets: The couple transferred their marital home and other assets worth approximately $4 million into the trust.


· The Trap: The wife was not named as a beneficiary; she was defined only as "Settlor's wife," meaning she would lose her status upon divorce.


· The "Typo": Section 5.5 stated the Settlor reserves "any power whatsoever" to alter or amend the trust, rather than "no power."



The Four Legal Hurdles

To recover her $2 million, the wife had to "run the table" on four critical issues:


1. Joinder: The trust was a separate legal entity and should have been joined as a defendant in the divorce. She only survived this error through "pure legal luck" when the Supreme Court joined the cases sua sponte.


2. Choice of Law: While the trust specified Nevada law, the Court ruled Utah’s public policy on equitable distribution took precedence.


3. Revocability: The Court held that an "unrestricted power to amend" includes the power to revoke.


4. Settlor Identity: Under Utah law, the wife was a settlor because she contributed property, allowing her to revoke the trust as to her $2 million contribution.



Key Takeaways for Wealth Professionals

For Attorneys


· Join the Trust Early: Always name an irrevocable trust as a necessary third party to ensure the court has jurisdiction over its assets.


· Draft with Precision: Avoid broad amendment powers in irrevocable trusts; consistency throughout the document is vital.


· Separate Counsel: Both spouses must have independent representation when transferring marital property into a trust.


For Wealth Managers & Fiduciaries


· The Offset Strategy: If a trust is truly irrevocable (like in the 2024 Oaks case), look for other assets to "offset" the value lost to the trust.


· Identify All Settlors: Remember that anyone who funds a trust may be legally considered a settlor with revocation rights.



Timeline

· 1992: Marriage.


· 2006: Husband files for divorce.


· July 2009: Wife’s lawyers file a separate lawsuit against the trust at the 11th hour.


· July 2010: Divorce decree signed; trust assets excluded from the division.


· August 2015: Utah Supreme Court consolidates the cases and rules in favor of the wife.



ABOUT THE HOST


Professor Kelly Lise Murray, JD is a lawyer and retired Vanderbilt Law School faculty member (18 years) specializing in wealth preservation strategies. She is a graduate of Stanford University (Phi Beta Kappa) and Harvard Law School (cum laude).


SUBSCRIBE:WealthLitigated.com QUESTIONS:WealthLitigated.com/questions


Disclaimer: This show is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or financial advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed.


#WealthLitigated #AssetProtection #IrrevocableTrust #DivorceLaw #EstatePlanning #UtahLaw #TrustLitigation #WealthManagement


Next Episode All Episodes Previous Episode

Listen for free

Show artwork for Wealth Litigated

About the Podcast

Wealth Litigated
Delivering all the drama of true crime...without the blood!
Delivering all the drama of true crime...without the blood! When a $50 million trust decants, a divorce destroys generational wealth, or a sophisticated fraud scheme fools the experts—your clients need you to see it coming. Welcome to Wealth Litigated, where real courtroom battles become your competitive advantage.
Host Kelly Lise Murray, JD, transforms complex courtroom outcomes into strategic intelligence for wealth managers, financial advisors, accountants, lawyers, mediators, and fiduciaries protecting client assets. A Stanford Univ. and Harvard Law-trained lawyer, legal scholar, and retired Vanderbilt Law faculty (18 years/retired 2023), Professor Murray dissects actual court cases of asset protection gone right and catastrophically wrong—from explosive family feuds over fortunes to white-collar financial crimes including fraud, embezzlement, Ponzi schemes, and title theft.
Story-driven and education-focused, each weekly episode answers the key question “How did it litigate?” and reveals what worked, what failed, and why it matters for your clients' wealth outcomes. Because litigating wealth costs more than money.
Subscribe now and stay ahead of the wealth protection challenges your clients face.

About your host

Profile picture for Kelly Lise Murray

Kelly Lise Murray

Kelly Lise Murray is a lawyer, professor, legal scholar, and serial entrepreneur focused on Wealth Dispute Resolution since 2007. Prof. Murray is passionate about helping preserve home ownership eligibility, especially in family disputes (Divorce, Trusts, Probate). She graduated Phi Beta Kappa from Stanford Univ., cum laude from Harvard Law School, and retired as faculty from Vanderbilt Law (after 18 years/she retired in 2023).

As a speaker and interdisciplinary continuing education trainer, Professor Murray has taught divorce mortgage and real estate to over 2,500 judges, lawyers, mediators, collaborative and financial professionals in 17+ states. In 2024, she presented a keynote concerning Divorce Mortgage at the IDFA (Institute of Divorce Financial Analysts) National Conference.

With an Illinois law license, and trained in family mediation and collaborative practice, Professor Murray is the host of the Wealth Litigated Podcast. She co-founded VettingTheHouse.com (in 2012) providing multi-state CLE and DivorceThisHouse.com (in 2008) providing divorce mortgage and real estate designation training to thousands.